Westminster (7-2) jumped out to an early 1-0 lead when Jace Maxfield scored on a cross from Dennis Sellis in the 21st minute.
Clay Stanger evened the score when he received a ball at point blank range from Nick Ebmeyer just 45 seconds before halftime.
Odaine Sinclair scored the game winner in the 68th minute when he received a cross from Ethan Bauer.
“We got better throughout the weekend and finished on a good note,” said head coach Nate Houser.
The Wildcats will be idle until next Saturday when they open up HAAC play against Central Methodist University at 7:30 p.m. CT.
“After last years tie, the guys are looking to put on a good performance on our home field,” said Houser.